Pilates Mat vs Yoga Mat: What’s the Difference (and Does It Matter?)

If you’re new to Pilates or training to become a Certified Pilates instructor you’ve probably heard people talk about Pilates vs yoga mats as if they’re the same thing. They’re similar, but not quite the same, and understanding the difference can be helpful.

So, let’s see what all the fuss is about — what the difference actually is, and what’s worth considering if you’re a student or Pilates instructor.

At a glance: Pilates mat vs yoga mat

The purpose behind each mat

Yoga mats: stability and grip

Yoga mats are designed to help you:

• feel grounded

• balance on one leg or two hands

• maintain grip during standing poses and transitions

They are thin by design, allowing you to feel the floor for stability and alignment. Too much padding in yoga can actually make balancing poses harder.

Pilates mats: support and comfort

Pilates, particularly classical matwork, involves:

• rolling through the spine

• sustained supine positions

• side-lying work

• pressure through the sacrum, spine, knees and hips

  
  

A traditional Pilates mat is therefore much thicker, offering cushioning and joint protection — especially for:

• the spine during rolling exercises

• clients with sensitive backs or knees

• longer floor-based sequences

Why mat thickness matters in Pilates

In Pilates, we often work in:

• spinal flexion

• spinal articulation

• sustained neutral or imprinted positions

  
  

Without adequate padding, clients may:

• tense unnecessarily

• avoid spinal movement

• experience discomfort that interferes with technique

A thicker mat allows the body to relax into movement, which is essential for breath, control and precision.

Here’s a studio-style Pilates mat that offers extra support without being bulky.

Can you use a yoga mat for Pilates?

Yes — but here are some things to consider

For home practice or beginner classes, a yoga mat can be acceptable if:

• additional padding is added when needed (e.g. folded towel, small cushion or blanket,)

• clients are comfortable and pain-free

However, when teaching understanding the difference is important. Using the correct equipment supports:

• safe movement

• client comfort

• professional standards

What Pilates instructors should know

If you’re training or newly qualified, it’s useful to remember:

• Pilates mats are traditionally thicker for a reason

• Client comfort affects movement quality

• Equipment choices reflect professionalism

You may not always control what mats are available in gyms or shared studios, but you can:

• adapt exercises

• offer padding options

• explain choices clearly to clients

These details matter more than people realise.

So… does it really matter?

It depends.

If you or your clients are moving well, feel supported, and aren’t experiencing pain or discomfort, then the mat you’re using is probably working just fine.

Many people practise Pilates happily on thinner mats, particularly for shorter sessions or less spinally loaded work. Comfort and confidence in movement always come first.

Where a thicker mat (or extra padding) can make a real difference is when:

• clients are hesitant to roll through the spine

• knees, hips or the lower back feel sensitive

• tension increases simply due to pressure from the floor

In these cases, small adaptations can improve comfort without needing specialist equipment.

Adapting Pilates exercises on a thinner mat

If you’re teaching in a gym or shared space where only yoga mats are available, consider using simple props such as a towel or blanket to support your clients.

Here are some common examples:

Kneeling exercises

Examples: kneeling arm work, cat stretch, quadruped stability

• Fold the mat or place a towel under the knees

• This reduces pressure and allows clients to focus on alignment rather than discomfort

  
  

Supine spinal articulation

Examples: pelvic curl, roll down, roll up

• Roll a small towel and place it under the lumbar spine or sacrum

• This can soften contact with the floor and encourage smoother spinal movement

  
  

Side-lying work

Examples: side kicks, clam variations

• A folded towel under the waist can help maintain neutral alignment

• Extra padding under the hip can reduce pressure on the greater trochanter

  
  

Prone positions

Examples: swimming prep, single leg kick

• A thin cushion or folded towel under the pelvis can ease lumbar compression

• This is especially helpful for clients with lower back sensitivity

  
  

Seated work

Examples: spine stretch forward, saw

• Sitting on a folded blanket can assist pelvic positioning

• This often makes spinal flexion more accessible and comfortable

  
  

A practical takeaway for instructors

Equipment doesn’t need to be perfect to be effective.

What matters is your ability as an instructor to:

• notice when a client is uncomfortable

• understand why that discomfort might be happening

• adapt intelligently using what’s available

These small decisions support better movement quality and they’re often the kind of details that make clients feel looked after and want to return to your classes.

Final thought

Pilates and yoga mats serve different purposes, but good Pilates teaching is adaptable.

If movement is comfortable and well supported, the mat is doing its job. When it isn’t, simple cushioning choices can make a meaningful difference.

Understanding when and how to make these adjustments is part of developing confidence as a Pilates instructor.

Interested in Pilates teacher training? Check out our courses in Chichester and Newquay. Already qualified? Sign up to our newsletter at the bottom of the page for Free instructor resources.